Neighbourhood shopping strips carry much of the social and economic life of a suburb, yet the evidence a council holds about them is rarely gathered in one place, and it is almost never collected in a way that lets one centre be compared fairly with another. A metropolitan Melbourne council came to this problem with four very different activity centres, close to 600 businesses between them, limited funds and several internal teams each holding a piece of the picture, from streetscape and trader relationships to planning controls. What it needed was not four more reports but one trusted evidence base, and from it a clear, comparable plan for each centre.
POMO was engaged by the council as lead consultant to deliver a Place Vision and Action Plan programme across all four centres, leading the strategy, the analysis and the design of every output. POMO worked alongside Fourfold Studio as engagement partner and RMIT University, which brought a behaviour and culture lens to how the evidence was framed and interpreted. This case study covers three things: how the team listened, how it made sense of what it heard, and how it showed the result back to the people who will use it.
The engagement was designed so that no single group could dominate the picture, which matters on shopping strips where the most frequent voices are not always the most representative ones. An online survey was open to anyone with a view on the four centres, with a dedicated pathway for business owners and operators, while traders were met door to door in their own shopfronts, pop-up sessions were held in the centres themselves, and the public conversation on the council’s own social media channels was read and coded alongside everything else.
Across a survey period of just over six weeks, this produced more than 700 survey responses, more than 280 coded social media comments and more than 50 recorded conversations, together more than 1,000 individual contributions. More than 500 comments and dot votes were also left on pop-up boards, and these are counted separately, because a dot vote is not a person.
Gathering input is only the start, and the harder work, which POMO treats as a discipline in its own right, is turning a large and uneven body of community and business input into evidence that is consistent, trustworthy and readable by people who are not specialists.
One Evidence Base, One Framework Every source was brought together into a single evidence base, cleaned, verified and de-identified before anything was counted, and every contribution, whether a survey response, a social media comment or a conversation on a footpath, was read through one analytical framework developed with RMIT University. The result is that the four centres were measured the same way and can be compared directly, rather than read as four separate stories.
Cross-centre comparison
Average rating out of 10. Because every centre answered the same questions, the four can be compared directly.
Triangulation over Volume Findings were treated as solid only where they held across independent sources, and where sources disagreed, the disagreement was treated as the finding rather than smoothed away. Parking was the issue most often raised in conversations with traders, yet in the survey of more than 700 people the look and feel of the public space was chosen as a barrier to visiting far more often than parking was, a distinction that matters a great deal for where a council chooses to direct its effort.
Survey result
Selections across all four centres, respondents could choose up to three. n = 1,140.
Triangulation
Share of each source’s coded contributions that raised the theme. A finding is treated as solid only when it holds across sources.
| Survey | Social media | Street conversations | Pop-up boards | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shade and greenery | 46% | 35% | 39% | 28% | ■ Holds in 4 of 4 |
| Footpath condition | 26% | 17% | 31% | 6% | ■ Holds in 3 of 4 |
| Public toilets | 16% | 9% | 5% | 48% | ■ One source only |
| Evening activity | 14% | 41% | 8% | 23% | ■ Sources disagree |
| Places for dogs | 7% | 12% | 4% | 9% | ■ Low in every source |
Live Evidence, Built in POMO Lab The programme draws on POMO Lab, the practice’s research and development arm, which integrates incoming data feeds with a live dashboard built for the client, so that the evidence stays current as new input arrives rather than being fixed in a report on the day it is printed.
Evidence Fitted to Each Reader POMO designed a family of outputs, each for a different reader and each in the council’s own brand palette, from the live view used by the project team to a plain-language insights page for wider readers and concise materials for council workshops, with sample sizes and caveats always in view.
Plain-language summary
Each card leads with what the evidence says in two or three sentences, then shows the numbers behind it.
Weekends are busy and weekdays are quiet. Shade, trees and better footpaths were raised in every source, by visitors and locals alike.
| Visit mostly on weekends | 81% | |
| Want more shade | 64% | |
| Walk or cycle here | 43% |
Most people arrive on foot from the surrounding streets and stay for a short visit. Public toilets and seating were the most common requests.
| Arrive on foot | 59% | |
| Want public toilets | 52% | |
| Stay over an hour | 18% |
Agreeing Before Writing Two workshops with the council’s internal teams turned the evidence into shared direction, moving the group from four separate reports toward one programme, a strategic overview plus a profile and action plan for each centre, all built on the same method. Before drafting began, a plain-language reverse brief played the brief back to the council so that audiences, purpose and format were agreed in advance, and the actions are being framed in delivery streams, from council-led through to trader-led and community-led, so that the documents enable action rather than commit budget.
The programme is still in progress, so the impact described here is the impact of the evidence work itself rather than of any change on the ground, which it is too early to claim. Engagement and analysis are complete, and the strategic overview and the four centre plans are being drafted for staged review by the council.
Contact POMO to discuss how we can turn your next engagement into evidence your council, your traders and your community can all read and act on.
Read next: Mackay Place Strategy: From Vision & Community Engagement to Activation
More projects
Miles Main Street Revitalisation: Regional Placemaking & Urban Renewal
Miles Main Street Revitalisation: Regional Placemaking & Urban Renewal
Regional town centres often struggle with generic urban design that fails to resonate with local history or encourage economic “stickiness.” In the heart of the Western Downs, the town of Miles required more than a standard streetscape upgrade; it needed a strategic revitalisation that could express its unique cultural heritage while fostering a renewed sense of community pride.
Mackay Place Strategy: From Vision to Activation
Mackay Place Strategy: From Vision to Activation
Mackay’s City Centre and Waterfront were facing a common regional challenge: despite significant investment in infrastructure, the public realm lacked the “stickiness” required to drive economic activity. The opening of a nearby major shopping centre and changing consumer habits had drained life from the streets.
